Is OC Raw or Smallbatch better for dogs?

OC Raw wins by 1 point on the v15 rubric (A/91 vs A/90) — effectively tied. Both are independent California-based small-batch freeze-dried raw brands. OC Raw’s edge: beef-led with beef tripe at #3 (rare whole-food prebiotic + enzyme), zero synthetic vitamin / mineral premix, 90% meat-and-organ ratio. Smallbatch’s edge: chicken-led with true prey-model carcass portions (skinless chicken necks + backs), twelve USDA-certified-organic produce ingredients, and single-source-farm Pacific NW sourcing. Pick on protein preference and prebiotic-vs-organic-produce priority.

Which has more organic ingredients, OC Raw or Smallbatch?

Smallbatch. The Chicken Sliders formulation includes twelve USDA-certified-organic produce ingredients (organic carrots, sweet potatoes, squash, broccoli, kale, collards, parsley, blueberry, kelp, wheatgrass, rosemary, basil) — the highest organic load in the freeze-dried raw category. OC Raw Beef & Produce Meaty Rox includes whole-food produce (carrots, apples, broccoli, spinach, acorn squash, beets, parsley, blueberries) but doesn’t carry explicit USDA-certified-organic status at the same coverage level. For owners specifically prioritizing organic-certified produce sourcing, Smallbatch is the structurally aligned pick.

Are OC Raw and Smallbatch both small-batch?

Yes. Both brands operate small-batch production models from California. OC Raw is based in Buena Park (Orange County, south of Los Angeles); Smallbatch is based in San Francisco with Pacific Northwest supplier sourcing. Both are independent of the major pet-food conglomerates (Mars, Nestle Purina, J.M. Smucker, General Mills). The structural difference is scale and sourcing concentration — OC Raw operates at slightly larger commercial scale with Midwest US meat sourcing; Smallbatch operates at tighter small-batch scale with Pacific Northwest single-source-farm sourcing transparency.

OC Raw vs Smallbatch: Which Is Better for Your Dog?

Disclosure: KibbleIQ is reader-supported. When you buy through affiliate links on this page (such as “Shop on Amazon” buttons), we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Our rankings are not influenced by commissions — we score every product using our published methodology before any commercial relationship is considered.

The short answer: OC Raw wins by 1 point on the v15 rubric (A/91 vs A/90) — effectively tied. Both are independently-owned California-based small-batch freeze-dried raw brands. OC Raw is beef-led with beef tripe at #3 (rare whole-food prebiotic + enzyme source), 90% meat-and-organ ratio, and zero synthetic vitamin / mineral premix in a 16-ingredient panel. Smallbatch is chicken-led with six chicken-derived top-7 ingredients including skinless chicken necks at #1 and chicken backs at #2 (true prey-model carcass portions), twelve organic-certified produce ingredients, and HPP-validated pathogen control. Pick on protein preference and prebiotic-vs-organic-produce priority.

The scores

OC Raw Beef & Produce Freeze-Dried Meaty Rox: A (91/100) — Beef, Ground Beef Bone, Beef Tripe, Beef Liver, Beef Heart.

Smallbatch Freeze-Dried Raw Chicken Sliders for Dogs: A (90/100) — Skinless Chicken Necks, Chicken Backs, Chicken, Chicken Livers, Chicken Gizzards.

How the ingredients compare

The top-five ingredients reveal the formulation split between these two products:

OC Raw: Beef, Ground Beef Bone, Beef Tripe, Beef Liver, Beef Heart

Smallbatch: Skinless Chicken Necks, Chicken Backs, Chicken, Chicken Livers, Chicken Gizzards

The 1-point gap (OC Raw wins by 1 point) shows where the v15 rubric weights ingredient breadth, protein density, and supplement depth differently.

Where OC Raw pulls ahead

Beef tripe at #3 (rare whole-food prebiotic + enzyme source): OC Raw includes beef tripe at primary position #3 — raw green tripe with naturally-occurring digestive enzymes, naturally-occurring lactobacilli at densities synthetic supplements can’t match, partially-digested forage, and short-chain fatty acids. For dogs with chronic GI sensitivity, IBD, or post-antibiotic dysbiosis, raw green tripe is often the single most-effective dietary intervention. Smallbatch doesn’t include tripe in the Chicken Sliders formulation. Shop on Amazon →

Zero synthetic vitamin / mineral premix (whole-food complete-and-balanced): OC Raw substantiates AAFCO completeness entirely from whole-food sources — no chelated trace minerals added, no synthetic vitamin E or D supplementation. Smallbatch includes three chelated trace minerals (zinc glycinate, copper glycinate, manganese glycinate) plus supplemental vitamin E. Both are short supplement tails by raw-pet-food standards, but OC Raw is structurally distinct in achieving AAFCO completeness with zero synthetic supplementation.

Beef-led recipe for owners avoiding chicken or during H5N1 outbreak surveillance: OC Raw Beef & Produce is beef-led; Smallbatch Chicken Sliders is chicken-led. For owners feeding beef as the protein anchor (chicken intolerance, palatability preference, or specifically avoiding poultry during active H5N1 outbreak windows for raw-poultry-transmission risk-management), OC Raw is the structurally aligned pick. Smallbatch offers beef, lamb, duck, turkey, and pork variants but the slider product reviewed here is chicken-based.

Where Smallbatch holds its own

Twelve organic-certified produce ingredients (highest organic load in category): Smallbatch includes organic carrots, organic sweet potatoes, organic squash, organic broccoli, organic kale, organic collards, organic parsley, organic blueberry, organic kelp, organic wheatgrass, organic rosemary, and organic basil. This is twelve USDA-certified-organic produce ingredients in a single recipe — the highest organic-produce load in the freeze-dried raw category. OC Raw includes carrots, apples, broccoli, spinach, acorn squash, beets, parsley, blueberries, basil powder, and kelp + alfalfa powder but without explicit USDA-certified-organic status at the same coverage level. Shop on Amazon →

Six chicken-derived top-7 ingredients including true prey-model carcass portions: Smallbatch leads with skinless chicken necks at #1 and chicken backs at #2 — bone-in carcass portions that deliver whole-prey calcium / phosphorus ratios directly through the bone content of the carcass portions themselves, not through supplemental ground bone. This is closer to a true ancestral / prey-model formulation than the typical ‘ground muscle + ground bone’ assembled approach. OC Raw uses ground beef bone at #2 (an excellent whole-prey approach but a step removed from carcass-portion delivery).

Single-source-farm sourcing transparency model: Smallbatch operates a Pacific Northwest single-source-farm sourcing model with direct supplier relationships, pasture-raised meat from regional family farms, and full farm-to-bag traceability disclosed publicly. OC Raw sources US-grown meat primarily from Midwest US farms with strong sourcing transparency claims but operates at slightly larger commercial scale. For owners specifically prioritizing single-source-farm transparency, Smallbatch is the structurally aligned pick.

The bottom line

OC Raw wins by 1 point (A/91 vs A/90) on the v15 rubric — effectively tied. Both are independently-owned California-based small-batch freeze-dried raw brands; both deliver A-tier whole-food raw nutrition with HPP-validated pathogen control. Pick on the trade-off you weight more heavily. OC Raw delivers beef-led recipe with beef tripe at #3, zero synthetic vitamin / mineral premix, 90% meat-and-organ ratio, and Meaty Rox loose-format precision portioning. Smallbatch delivers chicken-led recipe with true prey-model carcass portions (skinless chicken necks at #1, chicken backs at #2), twelve USDA-certified-organic produce ingredients (highest organic load in category), and single-source-farm Pacific Northwest sourcing model.