Is Diamond Naturals or Acana better dog food?

Acana wins by 12 points on the v15 rubric (A/90 vs B/78) — meaningful gap reflecting Acana's biologically-appropriate multi-protein formulation depth (beef + pork + beef meal + pork meal + lamb + organ meats + freeze-dried protein inclusions) vs Diamond Naturals' single-source chicken kibble structure (chicken + chicken meal + brown rice + barley + white rice). Diamond Naturals delivers a genuinely strong supplemental panel for its tier (kale + blueberries + glucosamine + chondroitin + spinach + papaya) at ~$1.10/lb, with grain-inclusive structure aligning with the DCM-precaution recommendation. Acana costs ~2.5× more but delivers multi-protein diversity, organ-meat inclusion, and Champion Petfoods' single-kitchen manufacturing transparency. Pick Diamond Naturals for budget-natural pricing with strong supplemental panel and DCM-precaution alignment. Pick Acana for multi-protein biologically-appropriate formulation and Champion Petfoods' single-source manufacturing.

Is the Diamond Naturals supplemental panel really comparable to mid-premium brands at its price point?

Yes — Diamond Naturals' supplemental panel is one of the structural reasons it scores B/78 at budget-natural pricing while many same-price-point brands score in the B/70-75 or C-tier range. The panel includes 11 whole-food fruit + vegetable inclusions (kale, chia seed, pumpkin, blueberries, oranges, quinoa, dried kelp, coconut, spinach, carrots, papaya) plus glucosamine hydrochloride and chondroitin sulfate for joint support plus the standard whole-grain + protein + fat structure. For comparison, many budget-natural brands include 3-5 whole-food supplemental ingredients and skip joint-support inclusions entirely. Diamond Naturals is positioned as Diamond Pet Foods' premium-natural sub-line within their multi-brand portfolio, and the supplemental panel reflects that positioning intent. The mid-premium brands (Acana, Fromm, Wellness Complete Health) deliver supplemental panel depth that's broadly comparable or modestly deeper, with the main differences being multi-protein structure (Acana) and full whole-food vegetable + cheese + chicken cartilage panel (Fromm) at the ~2× price point. For supplemental-panel depth alone, Diamond Naturals is structurally one of the strongest budget-natural picks.

Should I worry about Acana's legume content given the FDA DCM investigation?

The FDA's 2018-2022 investigation into diet-associated dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) identified a strong statistical association between grain-free legume-heavy formulations and DCM cases reported to the FDA. The investigation did NOT establish causation — the statistical association may reflect a true causal link, an indirect link mediated by an unknown nutritional deficiency or interaction, or a reporting artifact (grain-free brands are over-represented in the boutique / premium / direct-to-consumer category where owners may be more likely to file FDA reports). Acana Red Meat's post-reformulation panel is meaningfully legume-heavy: whole red lentils + whole pinto beans + whole green peas + whole green lentils + whole chickpeas + whole yellow peas collectively dominate positions 4-11 after the beef + pork + beef meal lead. The structural risk-asymmetry: switching to a grain-inclusive formulation (Wellness Complete Health, Fromm Gold, Diamond Naturals, Kirkland Signature, or many others) eliminates the precautionary concern entirely at modest cost; staying on grain-free legume-heavy formulations accepts a precautionary risk that the FDA and AVMA both flag. For owners with no specific reason to feed grain-free (no documented grain sensitivity, no elimination-diet protocol in progress), the structural recommendation is to favor grain-inclusive formulations as a precautionary default. For owners specifically needing grain-free formulations, Acana's reformulated panel is in the legume-heavy zone — consult your vet, especially for breeds with elevated DCM risk (Golden Retrievers, Doberman Pinschers, Great Danes, Boxers).

Diamond Naturals vs Acana: Is the Budget-Natural to Biologically-Appropriate Upgrade Worth It?

Disclosure: KibbleIQ is reader-supported. When you buy through affiliate links on this page (such as “Shop on Amazon” buttons), we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Our rankings are not influenced by commissions — we score every product using our published methodology before any commercial relationship is considered.

The short answer: Acana wins by 12 points on the v15 rubric (A/90 vs B/78) — meaningful gap reflecting Acana's biologically-appropriate multi-protein formulation depth (beef + pork + beef meal + pork meal + lamb + organ meats + freeze-dried protein inclusions) against Diamond Naturals' single-source chicken kibble structure. Diamond Naturals Adult Dog Chicken & Rice is structurally budget-natural: chicken + chicken meal in the dual-protein lead, whole grain brown rice + cracked pearled barley + white rice as the whole-grain carb base, chicken fat as the fat source, plus a genuinely strong supplemental panel for a budget-tier brand (kale + chia seed + pumpkin + blueberries + oranges + quinoa + dried kelp + coconut + spinach + carrots + papaya + glucosamine + chondroitin). Acana Red Meat is grain-free multi-protein biologically-appropriate: beef + pork as fresh-protein anchors, beef meal + pork meal as concentrated dried-protein, lamb at position #12 (recently reformulated), beef organ meats (tripe, liver, kidney) and pork organ meats (liver, kidney) in the upper-mid panel, plus freeze-dried beef + pork + lamb protein inclusions. The 12-point gap reflects Acana's multi-protein animal-source diversity, organ-meat inclusion, and biologically-appropriate philosophy vs Diamond Naturals' grain-inclusive single-protein structure — appropriate for different feeding scenarios and budget tiers.

The scores

Diamond Naturals Adult Dog Chicken & Rice: B (78/100) — Chicken, Chicken Meal, Whole Grain Brown Rice, Cracked Pearled Barley, White Rice.

Acana Red Meat Recipe: A (90/100) — Beef, Pork, Beef Meal, Whole Red Lentils, Whole Pinto Beans.

How the ingredients compare

The top-five ingredients reveal the formulation split between these two products:

Diamond Naturals: Chicken, Chicken Meal, Whole Grain Brown Rice, Cracked Pearled Barley, White Rice

Acana: Beef, Pork, Beef Meal, Whole Red Lentils, Whole Pinto Beans

The 12-point gap (Acana wins by 12 points) shows where the v15 rubric weights ingredient breadth, protein density, and supplement depth differently.

Where Diamond Naturals pulls ahead

Roughly 2.5× cheaper per pound — Diamond Pet Foods budget-natural pricing at ~$36-42 for a 35-pound bag: Diamond Naturals Adult Dog Chicken & Rice typically sells at $36-42 for a 35-pound bag at PetSmart, Petco, Amazon, Chewy, or Tractor Supply (~$1.03-1.20 per pound). Acana Red Meat typically sells at $70-80 for a 25-pound bag at PetSmart, Petco, or Chewy (~$2.80-3.20 per pound). For a 50-pound adult dog, the daily food cost difference is roughly $0.40-0.50 — about $145-180 per year in raw food cost. Given the 12-point rubric gap, the price-per-rubric-point ratio favors Diamond Naturals on a value basis. For budget-conscious households that specifically value the wide pet specialty + grocery-adjacent + Tractor Supply distribution accessibility plus Diamond Pet Foods' US family-owned manufacturing transparency, Diamond Naturals delivers B/78 nutrition at structurally accessible pricing. Shop on Amazon →

Grain-inclusive whole-grain structure — aligns with the legume-grain-free DCM hypothesis avoidance recommendation: Diamond Naturals Adult Dog uses whole grain brown rice + cracked pearled barley + white rice as the primary carbohydrate base — grain-inclusive with whole-grain structure rather than legume-anchored. The FDA's 2018-2022 investigation into diet-associated dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) identified a strong statistical association with grain-free legume-heavy formulas (peas, lentils, chickpeas as primary carb sources). The investigation didn't establish causation but produced enough signal that the AVMA and many veterinary cardiologists now recommend grain-inclusive formulas as a precautionary default. Acana Red Meat is grain-free with whole red lentils + whole pinto beans + whole green peas + whole green lentils + whole chickpeas + whole yellow peas as primary carbohydrate sources — aligned with the brand's biologically-appropriate philosophy but inside the legume-heavy formulation profile that triggered the DCM signal. For owners specifically wanting to avoid the legume-grain-free pattern as a precautionary measure, Diamond Naturals' grain-inclusive structure is the structurally safer pick.

Genuinely strong supplemental panel for a budget-tier brand — kale + chia seed + pumpkin + blueberries + oranges + quinoa + kelp + coconut + spinach + carrots + papaya + glucosamine + chondroitin: Diamond Naturals Adult Dog Chicken & Rice includes kale, chia seed, pumpkin, blueberries, oranges, quinoa, dried kelp, coconut, spinach, carrots, and papaya as whole-food supplemental panel ingredients, plus glucosamine hydrochloride and chondroitin sulfate for joint support. The supplemental panel is meaningfully deeper than typical budget-tier brands and is one of the structural reasons Diamond Naturals scores B/78 at this price point. For owners specifically valuing whole-food supplemental nutrition at budget-natural pricing, or wanting joint-support inclusions without the mid-premium price tag, Diamond Naturals delivers structurally strong supplemental nutrition.

Where Acana holds its own

Multi-protein beef + pork + lamb structure with organ-meat inclusion — deeper animal-source diversity than single-source chicken: Acana Red Meat leads with beef + pork as fresh-protein anchors immediately backed by beef meal + pork meal (concentrated dried-protein forms) and includes lamb at position #12 plus beef tripe, beef liver, beef kidney, pork liver, and pork kidney as organ-meat panel positions in the upper-mid formula. The structure delivers measurably deeper animal-protein diversity than Diamond Naturals' single-source chicken structure: three named mammalian proteins instead of one poultry protein, broader amino acid profile, organ-meat preformed vitamin A + B12 + iron + folate density, plus the freeze-dried beef + pork + lamb supplemental protein inclusions. For owners specifically valuing multi-protein animal-source diversity, organ-meat inclusion, or biologically-appropriate WholePrey-style nutritional philosophy, Acana is structurally aligned. Shop on Amazon →

Champion Petfoods biologically-appropriate (BAFRINO) formulation + DogStar Kitchens Auburn KY single-source manufacturing: Acana is formulated under Champion Petfoods' BAFRINO philosophy (Biologically Appropriate, Fresh Regional Ingredients, Never Outsourced) and manufactured at Champion's owned-and-operated DogStar Kitchens facility in Auburn, Kentucky (US-market product) with regional ingredient sourcing from Kentucky-region farms, ranches, and fisheries. The single-kitchen single-brand manufacturing model means tight quality-control over ingredient handling end-to-end. Diamond Naturals is manufactured at Diamond Pet Foods facilities that also produce Kirkland Signature, Taste of the Wild, 4Health, Chicken Soup, and several other private-label brands — multi-brand shared-facility model. For owners specifically valuing single-kitchen single-brand traceability, regional ingredient sourcing transparency, or Champion Petfoods' BAFRINO biologically-appropriate philosophy, Acana is structurally aligned.

Freeze-dried beef + pork + lamb protein inclusions + Lactobacillus / Bifidobacterium probiotic blend — raw-style nutritional density baked into kibble + digestive support: Acana Red Meat includes freeze-dried beef, freeze-dried pork, and freeze-dried lamb as supplemental protein inclusions in the formula plus a three-strain probiotic blend (Lactobacillus acidophilus + Bifidobacterium animalis + Lactobacillus casei) for digestive support. Freeze-drying preserves heat-sensitive nutrients (some enzymes, certain bioactive lipid forms, some B vitamins) that conventional hot-extrusion kibble manufacturing degrades. The freeze-dried inclusions deliver a small but meaningful raw-style nutritional density boost on top of the kibble base. Diamond Naturals uses standard hot-extrusion kibble processing without freeze-dried protein inclusions, though it does include a probiotic strain (no equivalent three-strain blend). For owners specifically valuing raw-style nutrient preservation, freeze-dried protein inclusions, or three-strain digestive-support probiotic blends, Acana is structurally aligned.

The bottom line

Acana wins by 12 points (A/90 vs B/78) — meaningful gap driven by multi-protein animal-source diversity and biologically-appropriate formulation depth. Pick Diamond Naturals Adult Dog Chicken & Rice when family-owned US manufacturing transparency at budget-natural pricing is the priority: B/78 nutrition at ~$1.10/lb, grain-inclusive DCM-precaution alignment, genuinely strong supplemental panel for a budget-tier brand (kale + chia seed + pumpkin + blueberries + glucosamine + chondroitin), wide distribution at Tractor Supply + PetSmart + Petco + Chewy + Amazon. Pick Acana Red Meat Recipe when multi-protein biologically-appropriate nutrition is the priority: beef + pork + lamb multi-source protein lead, organ-meat panel inclusion (beef tripe + beef liver + beef kidney + pork liver + pork kidney), freeze-dried protein inclusions, three-strain probiotic blend, and Champion Petfoods DogStar Kitchens single-kitchen manufacturing. The 12-point rubric gap is meaningful but Diamond Naturals' strong supplemental panel narrows the practical-feeding-outcome gap for budget-conscious households — this is one of the more defensible "stay on the budget option" decisions in this round.