Is Answers Pet Food or Primal better for dogs?

Effectively tied at A/90 vs A/90 on the v15 rubric. Answers Pet Food leads with the deep raw-fermented-dairy layer (whey + butter + kefir with four named Lactobacillus strains) and five named organ meats + cod liver. Primal leads with High Pressure Processing (HPP) pathogen control, broad retail distribution, and dairy-free standard formulation. Pick Answers for fermentation philosophy and dogs needing high natural probiotic load. Pick Primal for HPP-mitigated pathogen safety, dairy-allergic dogs, and broader retail availability.

What is HPP and does Answers Pet Food use it?

HPP (High Pressure Processing) is a cold pasteurization technique that applies 87,000+ PSI pressure to packaged raw food to inactivate Salmonella, E. coli, Listeria, and Campylobacter to safe levels while preserving raw nutritional structure (no heat applied). Primal uses HPP on most raw products. Answers Pet Food does not use HPP — the brand’s formulation philosophy holds that lactic-acid fermentation provides natural pathogen-inhibition, but this is mechanistically different from HPP’s direct pressure inactivation. For households with immunocompromised members where pathogen-load mitigation is the binding constraint, HPP-treated raw or fully-cooked alternatives are structurally safer category-level choices.

Answers Pet Food vs Primal: Which Is Better for Your Dog?

Q: Does Primal include fermented dairy like Answers Pet Food?

No. Primal’s standard formulations are dairy-free. Primal includes probiotic supplementation in the supplement section (typically guaranteed-stability synthetic probiotic strains) but doesn’t use fermented dairy as a structural recipe component. Answers Pet Food’s Detailed Beef Formula explicitly includes whey + butter + kefir with four named Lactobacillus strains at densities synthetic supplementation can’t match. For owners specifically wanting deep natural probiotic load from fermented food, Answers is the structurally aligned pick. For owners wanting probiotic support without dairy, Primal’s synthetic probiotic supplementation is the dairy-free alternative.

Disclosure: KibbleIQ is reader-supported. When you buy through affiliate links on this page (such as “Shop on Amazon” buttons), we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Our rankings are not influenced by commissions — we score every product using our published methodology before any commercial relationship is considered.

The short answer: Effectively tied at A/90 vs A/90 on the v15 rubric. Both are A-tier frozen-raw beef recipes from independent US brands. Answers Pet Food leads with whole-prey-model beef plus a uniquely deep raw-fermented-dairy layer (whey + butter + kefir with four named Lactobacillus strains). Primal Pronto leads with beef-with-ground-bone in primary position followed by beef liver, organic produce (squash, carrots, kale), and uses High Pressure Processing (HPP) pathogen control before freezing. Pick on probiotic philosophy (fermentation vs HPP-mitigated raw), dairy inclusion, and produce ingredient breadth.

The scores

Answers Pet Food Detailed Beef Formula: A (90/100) — Beef, Beef Heart, Beef Liver, Beef Kidney, Ground Beef Bone.

Primal Pronto Beef Recipe Frozen Raw: A (90/100) — Beef with Ground Bone, Beef Liver, Organic Squash, Organic Carrots, Organic Kale.

How the ingredients compare

The top-five ingredients reveal the formulation split between these two products:

Answers: Beef, Beef Heart, Beef Liver, Beef Kidney, Ground Beef Bone

Primal: Beef with Ground Bone, Beef Liver, Organic Squash, Organic Carrots, Organic Kale

Both products earn effectively the same v15 score, but the ingredient lineups tell different stories about how they got there — that is where the actual pick decision lives.

Where Answers pulls ahead

Raw-fermented dairy layer with four named Lactobacillus strains: Answers includes whey + butter + kefir with four named strains (L. bulgaricus, L. acidophilus, Leuconostoc mesenteroides, L. lactis) at densities synthetic probiotic supplementation can’t match. Primal includes a probiotic supplement at lower CFU density and doesn’t use fermentation as a primary brand differentiator. For dogs with chronic GI sensitivity or microbiome-axis issues benefiting from high probiotic load, Answers is structurally specialized. Shop on Amazon →

Five named organ meats + cod liver for whole-food vitamin density: Answers includes beef + beef heart + beef liver + beef kidney + ground beef bone in positions #1-#5, plus cod liver at #9 for marine vitamin D and natural EPA + DHA in whole-food matrix form. Primal includes beef-with-ground-bone (combined entry) + beef liver but doesn’t name kidney as a separate ingredient or include cod liver. For owners specifically prioritizing maximum organ-meat density and direct marine vitamin D, Answers’ ingredient depth is structurally meaningful.

Organic produce + organic chicken eggs: Answers includes organic carrots, organic chicken eggs (for choline and complete amino acids), organic green squash, organic broccoli, organic parsley. Primal uses organic produce (organic squash, organic carrots, organic kale) but doesn’t include eggs. For owners specifically wanting whole-food eggs as a complete-amino-acid source plus organic produce breadth, Answers is structurally aligned.

Where Primal holds its own

High Pressure Processing (HPP) pathogen control before freezing: Primal uses HPP — a cold pasteurization technique that applies 87,000+ PSI pressure to packaged raw food to inactivate Salmonella, E. coli, Listeria, and Campylobacter to safe levels while preserving raw nutritional structure (no heat). HPP-treated raw is structurally safer than non-HPP frozen raw for households with immunocompromised members. Answers does not use HPP; the brand’s formulation philosophy holds that fermentation provides natural pathogen-inhibition via lactic-acid production, but this is mechanistically different from HPP’s direct pressure inactivation. Shop on Amazon →

Broad retail distribution + established multi-decade brand track record: Primal has been operating since 2001 with broad distribution across PetSmart, Petco, Chewy.com, Amazon, and independent pet retailers nationwide. Answers (Lystn LLC) has a shorter brand history with a notable 2018 FDA Salmonella regulatory dispute. For owners specifically prioritizing longer brand track record, broad retailer availability, and HPP-mitigated pathogen safety, Primal is the structural pick.

Dairy-free standard formulation: Primal’s standard formulations are dairy-free, appropriate for dogs with confirmed dairy allergy or severe lactose intolerance. Answers Detailed Beef Formula includes whey, butter, and kefir — the fermented-dairy layer is contraindicated for dairy-allergic dogs. For owners feeding dairy-allergic dogs wanting raw whole-prey-model nutrition with HPP pathogen control, Primal is the structural alternative.

The bottom line

Effectively tied at A/90 vs A/90 — the pick comes down to probiotic philosophy and dairy tolerance. Pick Answers Pet Food for the deep raw-fermented-dairy layer (whey + butter + kefir with four named Lactobacillus strains), five named organ meats + cod liver for direct marine vitamin D, and organic chicken eggs. Pick Primal for HPP pathogen control (structurally safer for immunocompromised-household feeding), broad retail distribution across PetSmart / Petco / Chewy.com / Amazon, dairy-free standard formulation, and established multi-decade brand track record.